How to calculate design variants in the same version
Purpose
Section titled “Purpose”Calculate two or more solutions in the same version, for example two window types, a brick facade against a timber facade, or a generic value against a specific EPD. The variants share one building model, so a correction in the shared part applies to all of them. The only thing that sets them apart is which constructions and building products are included.
Prerequisites
Section titled “Prerequisites”- You can edit the version, and it is not locked and archived.
- Everything other than which lines are included is shared by the variants: quantities, areas, reference study period, start year, calculation mode, building type, operation, construction site and the transport default values. If any of that needs to differ, make a copy of the version instead, see How to copy a version.
Create the variants
Section titled “Create the variants”- Open the version, and click + Design variant in the project menu under the version’s name.
LCAbyg creates two variants, A and B. Both contain the whole current model, and A is the selected one. The badge Variant A now stands under the version’s name on every page of the project.
Choose what each variant contains
Section titled “Choose what each variant contains”- Go to Building model, and select a construction or building product in the tree.
- The detail panel shows In variant: with a checkbox per variant. Clear the checkbox for the variants the line should not be in.
- If a variant needs a solution that is not in the model yet, insert it from the library as usual. The insert dialog shows In: all variants. Click it, and choose the variants the new line should be in.
An example with a generic value against a specific EPD: insert the building product with the specific EPD only in B, and clear the checkbox for B on the generic building product. A then calculates on the generic value and B on the EPD.
If you exclude a construction in a variant, everything under it is also out of that variant. If a line needs a different quantity in one of the variants, copy the line, change the quantity in the copy, and include the original and the copy in one variant each.
Switch variant
Section titled “Switch variant”- Click the badge Variant A under the version’s name, and choose another variant in the Design variants menu.
Compare the variants
Section titled “Compare the variants”- Go to General information, and open the Compare selector above the charts. Each variant is listed as its own item with both the version’s and the variant’s name. Tick the variants you want to compare. If the project’s default version has variants, they are selected from the start (at most four).
The charts show the variants side by side, see also How to compare two versions.
Result
Section titled “Result”The selected variant is the one the version is calculated on everywhere: the building model, the results, the limit values, the report, the exports and the figures in the project list. If you switch variant, the switch applies to everyone working in the version.
In the building model’s tree you can see how the lines are distributed:
- A line that is excluded in the selected variant is shown with a hollow circle. If you hover over it, it says Excluded in and the variant’s name.
- A line that is only in some of the variants has a badge with their names, for example A C.
- A line that is excluded in all variants gets the warning In no design variant and is listed in the summary of calculation errors, because it is not part of any calculation.
If you want to change many lines at once, switch on In the selected variant in the View menu. The tree then gets a column with a checkbox for the selected variant on each line.
Create more, rename or delete variants
Section titled “Create more, rename or delete variants”Click the badge under the version’s name to open the Design variants menu:
- Create new variant adds one more variant with the next free letter. It contains the whole model and is not selected by itself.
- The pencil next to a variant opens Rename design variant. Enter a new Name, and click Save.
- The bin deletes the variant. The dialog says how many lines are only in that variant: they are not in any variant afterwards. If you delete the selected variant, the dialog says which variant is selected instead. Click Delete variant to confirm.
If you delete the last variant, the version is without design variants again. Lines that were only excluded in a variant are then calculated again.
Good to know
Section titled “Good to know”- Include in calculation is shared by all variants. If you switch it off, the line is out of all of them, see How to exclude something from the calculation.
- If you copy a construction or building product inside the project, the copy is in all variants.
- A copy of the version takes the variants along.
- If you only have read access, or the version is locked and archived, you only see the selected variant and cannot switch.
- The report, the Excel export and the BR sheet write the name of the selected variant. An LCAbyg project file contains all the variants, while a file in the LCAbyg 2023 format only gets the selected one, because LCAbyg 2023 does not know design variants.