Skip to content
Support
Machine-translated from Danish

How to calculate design variants when the quantities come from a model

Calculate design variants in a version where the quantities come from a model, for example sent with the Revit plugin or uploaded as a Revit schedule or spreadsheet. The variants should keep following the model’s quantities when you send the model again.

When you approve a submission under Models, each type from the model is linked to one construction that sits directly in a category in the building model. On the next submission, only the linked construction’s quantity is updated. A submission never touches a construction that is not linked to the model.

That is why the usual way of making a variant does not work here. If you copy the linked construction, or insert a new construction next to it, the new one is not linked to the model. Its quantity stays put while the linked construction follows the model, and then the variants are no longer calculated on the same building.

Instead, the difference between the variants has to sit inside the linked construction. Building products and sub-constructions in a construction have an amount per unit of the construction, for example per m², so they follow along when the model changes the construction’s quantity. A submission does not touch what you add inside the construction yourself either. There are two ways to do it:

  • Building products in variants: the alternative building products sit side by side in the linked construction. This suits small differences, for example a different insulation, or a specific EPD instead of a generic value.
  • Sub-constructions in variants: the linked construction holds the model’s quantity and contains one sub-construction per variant. This suits whole build-ups, for example a brick facade against a timber facade.
  • The model has been sent, and the submission has been approved, so the types are linked to constructions. See Models and Revit plugin.
  • The version has design variants, see How to calculate design variants in the same version.
  • The variants are in the project’s default version. That is the version shown in the green field on General information. The Revit plugin and the review under Models call it the active version. When you approve a submission, LCAbyg makes a copy of the default version with the model’s new quantities, and the copy becomes the new default version. If you made the variants in another version, they are not included in the copy. So make the version with the variants the default version before you approve, see How to make a version the default version. If a submission is already waiting, the review says that the active version has changed. Click Move to active version before you approve.
  • The linked construction is not locked. If you chose Construction from a library in the review, it is locked, and you have to unlock it first, see How to unlock a construction that comes from the library. The link to the model is kept when you unlock. Constructions from Create from the type’s layers and Create an empty construction are your own and are not locked.
  1. Go to Building model, and find the construction the model’s type is linked to.
  2. Open the row’s menu, and choose Insert from the library or Create building product to add the alternative building product. Enter the amount per unit of the construction, for example per m², just like the building products already in it. If you insert from the library, you can choose the variants under In: all variants right away.
  3. Select the building products one at a time, and tick the boxes under In variant: in the detail panel, so each building product is only in the variants it belongs to. For example, the current insulation is only in A and the new one only in B.

Building products that are the same in all variants you leave in all of them.

  1. Go to Building model, and find the construction the model’s type is linked to, for example an external wall of 450 m². It keeps the link and the quantity from the model.

  2. Open the row’s menu, and choose Create construction. Give the sub-construction a name after the variant, for example “External wall, brick”. Choose the same Unit as the linked construction, set Amount to 1, and click Create construction.

    The amount 1 means 1 m² of sub-construction per m² of the linked construction, so the sub-construction is calculated with the model’s full quantity.

  3. Add the sub-construction’s building products with Insert from the library or Create building product in its menu, with amounts per m². If you already have the build-up as a construction in the building model, you can instead move it in with Cut and Paste and change its amount to 1, see How to move a construction or product.

  4. Repeat steps 2 and 3 for each variant, for example “External wall, timber”.

  5. Select the sub-constructions one at a time, and tick the boxes under In variant: in the detail panel, so each sub-construction is only in its own variant.

If there are already building products directly in the linked construction, they count in all variants on top of the sub-constructions. Move them into the sub-construction they belong to with Cut and Paste. Only building products that are shared by all variants can stay.

Do not clear the box for the linked construction itself. If you exclude it in a variant, everything under it is also out in that variant.

If the type is new in the model, you can choose Create an empty construction for it in the review. Then the linked construction is empty and unlocked from the start, with the model’s quantity. If you have already built the construction with sub-constructions in the version, you can instead link the type to it with Existing construction in the version.

Each variant is calculated on its own build-up, but with the same quantity from the model. If you send the model again and approve the submission, the linked construction’s quantity is updated, and all variants follow along. The new version the approval creates has the same variants and the same choices of what is included in each variant.

  • If the type’s layer build-up changes in the model, the review says The layer build-up has changed in the model. The building products in the construction do not change by themselves, so correct them in each variant to match the new layers.
  • If the type disappears from the model, the review asks what should happen to the construction. Delete the construction also deletes everything under it, in all variants. Keep the construction as your own keeps it, but then it no longer follows the model.
  • The review of a submission does not know about the variants, so whatever an approval creates is in all variants. That applies to constructions for new types in the model, and with a spreadsheet also to new building products that the sheet puts in a linked construction. After the approval, check which variants the new lines should be in.
  • If a variant needs a different quantity than the model, for example a different window area, try it out with a construction that is not linked to the model. Include it only in that variant, and exclude the linked construction in the same variant. The quantity does not follow the model, so you have to correct it yourself.
  • Revit’s design options do not become design variants in LCAbyg. The plugin only sends the primary design option, so you make the variants in LCAbyg as described here.